Check a claim yourself
You don’t need a science degree to spot a weak claim. These ten questions are the same ones behind every Unmythed article. Most claims that go viral fail at least one of them.
-
What exactly is being claimed?
Pin the claim down. “Turmeric is good for you” can’t be tested. “Turmeric capsules lower blood pressure in adults” can. Vague claims are hard to prove wrong, which is often why they’re vague.
-
Who is making it, and what do they gain?
Someone selling a product, a course or a cure has a reason to believe it works. That doesn’t make them wrong, but it means the claim needs independent support.
-
Where is the evidence?
“It worked for me” and “my grandmother always said” are stories, not evidence. Stories are where good questions start. Studies are where they get answered. Look for a link to actual research, not to another article repeating the claim.
-
What kind of study is it?
Some studies are much stronger than others. From strongest to weakest: systematic reviews, randomised controlled trials, observational studies, case reports, and anecdotes. Results from cells in a dish or from animals often don’t hold up in people.
-
How big, and how careful?
A study of 20 people can easily produce a fluke. Look for a large sample, a control group to compare against, and ideally blinding, so expectations can’t colour the results.
-
Is it cause, or just a connection?
Ice cream sales and drownings both rise in summer, but ice cream doesn’t cause drowning. Hot weather drives both. When two things move together, ask whether something else explains them. Researchers call this confounding.
-
How big is the effect, really?
“Doubles your risk” sounds alarming. But if the risk goes from 1 in 10,000 to 2 in 10,000, the real change is tiny. Always ask for the absolute risk, not just the relative one.
-
Has anyone else found the same thing?
One study is a starting point, not a conclusion. Results that hold up are repeated by other teams in other places. Be wary of headlines built on a single paper.
-
What does the wider body of research say?
Anyone can find one study that agrees with them. The better question is what most of the evidence shows. Systematic reviews and reports from scientific bodies exist to answer exactly that.
-
Is it built to make you feel something?
Claims designed to spread often lean on fear, outrage or wonder: “doctors don’t want you to know”, “share before it’s deleted”, “one simple trick”. Strong emotion and urgency are a signal to slow down, not speed up.
Before you forward it
A quick check before sharing a message on WhatsApp or social media:
- Can you find the original source, not just a screenshot?
- Is there a date? Old news gets recirculated as new.
- Does a credible health or science organisation say the same?
- Would you be comfortable if the person you send it to asked, “How do you know?”
If you’re not sure, don’t forward it. Or send it to Unmythed and I’ll take a look.
New to the terms above? The glossary explains them in plain language.